The market continued to rally on Tuesday with all three major indexes finishing the session higher by around 1%. The Dow’s 230 points back-to-back advance in two days was the biggest in three months. Investors were encouraged by a positive report from the housing front and the recent selling also provided some investors a good entry point. Pending home sales for December rose 1% and marked the ninth improvement over the past 10 months. In other stories, Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner told the Senate Finance Committee that the economy is in better shape compared to a year ago while the government still needs to take efforts to bring down unemployment. On Friday, we are going to get the non-farm payroll report for January.
In the past market comments, I argued that the market should eventually move higher due to very reasonable valuation. To further illustrate this point, I spent some time comparing the current Dow components prices with prices 10 years ago(note: a couple of Dow components have been replaced during the past decade but this should not change the overall picture. In addition, price for Kraft was based on June 14 2001, when it was spinned off). The table is listed below and some interesting statistics are shown at the bottom of the table.
Company Name |
Current Share Price(Feb 1st 2010) |
Current Market Cap(in Bils) |
Forward P/E (Based on 2010 earnings estimation) |
Sales estimated for 2010(in Bils) |
Net Margin |
Dividend Yield |
3M |
80.44 |
57.16 |
15.90 |
25.15 |
14.30% |
2.54% |
Alcoa |
13.36 |
13.02 |
16.29 |
21.57 |
3.70% |
0.90% |
American Express |
38.21 |
45.55 |
14.53 |
26.36 |
11.89% |
1.88% |
AT&T |
25.38 |
149.79 |
11.54 |
124.26 |
10.45% |
6.62% |
Bank of America |
15.42 |
133.39 |
19.04 |
115.17 |
6.08% |
0.26% |
Boeing |
61.7 |
46.64 |
14.98 |
65.06 |
4.79% |
2.72% |
Caterpillar |
52.94 |
32.97 |
19.68 |
36.83 |
4.55% |
3.17% |
Chevron |
73.58 |
146.71 |
9.35 |
184.33 |
8.51% |
3.70% |
Cisco Systems |
22.73 |
130.76 |
15.78 |
37.81 |
21.91% |
0.00% |
EI Du Pont |
33.66 |
30.42 |
14.38 |
29.07 |
7.27% |
4.87% |
Exxon Mobil |
66.18 |
314.18 |
11.35 |
385.89 |
7.17% |
2.54% |
General Electric |
16.25 |
173.02 |
16.41 |
154.07 |
6.84% |
2.46% |
Hewlett-Packard |
47.83 |
113.08 |
11.00 |
119.76 |
8.59% |
0.67% |
Intel Corp |
19.61 |
108.29 |
12.03 |
40.57 |
22.19% |
3.21% |
IBM |
124.67 |
163.32 |
11.21 |
99.66 |
14.62% |
1.76% |
Johnson & Johnson |
63.09 |
174.07 |
12.82 |
64.54 |
21.03% |
3.11% |
JP Morgan & Chase |
39.63 |
156.22 |
13.04 |
105.8 |
11.33% |
0.50% |
Kraft Foods |
28.06 |
41.41 |
12.93 |
43.11 |
7.43% |
4.13% |
McDonald's Corp |
63.89 |
68.95 |
14.45 |
23.87 |
19.98% |
3.44% |
Merck&Co Inc. |
38.3 |
116.99 |
11.07 |
45.39 |
23.28% |
3.97% |
Microsoft Corporation |
28.41 |
249.17 |
14.87 |
60.92 |
27.50% |
1.83% |
Pfizer Inc |
18.79 |
151.63 |
8.28 |
67.42 |
27.17% |
3.83% |
Coca-Cola |
54.38 |
126.01 |
15.85 |
32.94 |
24.13% |
3.02% |
Home Depot |
28.39 |
48.27 |
18.20 |
65.36 |
4.06% |
3.17% |
Procter & Gamble |
61.99 |
180.06 |
14.97 |
79.95 |
15.04% |
2.84% |
Travelers |
50.69 |
27.7 |
8.71 |
21.21 |
14.99% |
2.60% |
United Technologies |
67.55 |
63.33 |
14.65 |
54.63 |
7.91% |
2.28% |
Verizon Communications |
29.61 |
83.97 |
12.55 |
108.81 |
6.15% |
6.42% |
Wal-Mart Stores |
53.48 |
203.77 |
14.81 |
409.1 |
3.36% |
2.04% |
Walt Disney |
29.52 |
55.06 |
15.46 |
37.02 |
9.62% |
1.19% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Statistics |
|
3404.91 |
13.87 |
2685.63 |
12.5% |
2.72% |
Company Name |
Share Price at Jan 1st 2000 |
Market Cap at Jan 1st 2000(In Bils) |
2000 sales |
Net Margin |
P/E (Based on 2000 real earnings) |
Dividend Yield (2000) |
3M |
97.87 |
39.78 |
16.70 |
11.12% |
21.42 |
2.29% |
Alcoa |
83 |
30.52 |
22.66 |
6.52% |
20.67 |
0.97% |
American Express |
166.25 |
227.60 |
22.18 |
12.67% |
81.00 |
0.54% |
AT&T |
48.75 |
167.36 |
47.17 |
16.54% |
21.46 |
1.97% |
Bank of America |
50.19 |
84.18 |
43.26 |
18.18% |
10.71 |
1.99% |
Boeing |
41.44 |
38.37 |
51.32 |
4.15% |
18.03 |
1.54% |
Caterpillar |
47.06 |
16.72 |
20.18 |
5.22% |
15.88 |
1.38% |
Chevron |
86.62 |
61.72 |
52.13 |
9.95% |
11.90 |
2.86% |
Cisco Systems |
107.12 |
378.24 |
18.93 |
14.10% |
141.77 |
0.00% |
EI Du Pont |
65.87 |
72.32 |
28.27 |
8.19% |
31.25 |
2.13% |
Exxon Mobil |
80.56 |
280.11 |
227.60 |
6.94% |
17.72 |
2.09% |
General Electric |
154.75 |
515.63 |
129.85 |
9.81% |
40.49 |
0.36% |
Hewlett-Packard |
113.75 |
239.44 |
48.87 |
7.29% |
67.24 |
0.56% |
Intel Corp |
82.31 |
547.20 |
33.73 |
31.24% |
51.94 |
0.07% |
IBM |
107.87 |
195.09 |
85.09 |
9.25% |
24.78 |
0.44% |
Johnson & Johnson |
93.25 |
129.62 |
29.17 |
16.98% |
26.17 |
1.17% |
JP Morgan & Chase |
77.69 |
143.77 |
60.07 |
9.53% |
25.10 |
2.11% |
Kraft Foods |
30.15 |
48.54 |
22.92 |
8.73% |
24.26 |
1.72% |
McDonald's Corp |
40.31 |
54.45 |
14.24 |
13.88% |
27.54 |
0.50% |
Merck&Co Inc. |
67.19 |
156.49 |
40.36 |
16.90% |
22.94 |
1.80% |
Microsoft Corporation |
116.75 |
640.02 |
22.96 |
41.04% |
67.94 |
0.00% |
Pfizer Inc |
32.44 |
204.92 |
29.57 |
19.50% |
35.53 |
0.92% |
Coca-Cola |
58.25 |
127.39 |
20.46 |
10.64% |
58.52 |
1.10% |
Home Depot |
68.75 |
158.42 |
45.74 |
5.64% |
61.38 |
1.66% |
Procter & Gamble |
109.56 |
109.72 |
39.95 |
8.87% |
30.98 |
0.58% |
Travelers |
33.69 |
7.68 |
37.00 |
2.68% |
7.74 |
3.09% |
United Technologies |
65 |
32.94 |
26.58 |
6.80% |
18.22 |
0.62% |
Verizon Communications |
61.56 |
170.95 |
64.71 |
16.71% |
15.81 |
2.50% |
Wal-Mart Stores |
69.12 |
307.86 |
191.33 |
3.29% |
48.91 |
0.29% |
Walt Disney |
29.25 |
60.14 |
25.33 |
3.63% |
65.37 |
0.89% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Statistics |
|
5247.20 |
1518.31 |
11.9% |
37.09 |
1.27% |
From the table above, we can find a couple of interesting things:
1. Stock prices are much cheaper now compared to a decade ago. Average PE ratio has dropped from 37 times earnings to less than 14 times estimated earnings. This can also be seen from dividend yield, which increased from an average of 1.27% to a current reading of 2.72%;
2. The damage of the tech bubble can still be felt today. Several tech companies in the Dow, including Cisco and Microsoft, are currently traded at less than half of their market value for 2000 although their sales have more than doubled since then;
3. The Dow 30 usually accounts for roughly 30% of overall US market cap. Back in 2000, the total US market cap was around $15 trillion, or more than 1.5 times of then GDP of around $9.9 trillion. Today, the total US cap is a little more than $10 trillion, or less than 75% of the current GDP of around $14.3 trillion. Interestingly, big companies managed to increase their sales much faster compared to the overall GDP growth. The total sales of the Dow 30 companies have increased almost 80% from 1.518 trillion to 2.685 trillion during the past decade while GDP increased less than 50% in the same period. One reason can be expansion in the overseas market;
4. Although sales have increased by almost 80% in the past decade, margins have stayed pretty much flat for the period. The average net margin of 30 Dow companies have improved only slightly from 11.9% to today's 12.5%. Historically the net margin in the US companies is between 5% and 10%. And the Dow companies are obviously outstanding in this front.
All 10 major sectors finished the session higher led by health care and industrials. The CRB commodity index rose 1.9%. The US dollar was lower against most major currencies. Treasury yields were little changed. The three-month US LIBOR was unchanged at 25 bps. The VIX index dropped more than 1 points. The market breath was positive on both NYSE and Nasdaq. The volume was a little heavier compared to the previous session.
|